Like the 1918 nickel, some variations of the 1916 Buffalo five-cent piece contain errors. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. Although 18,700 proof copies of the 1941 nickel were struck, most entered circulation. The Most Valuable Nickels, 1942-D Over Horizontal D Jefferson Nickel, 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Three and a Half Legs, 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse, 1964 Jefferson Nickel Mirror Brockage: $1,153,000, 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse: $504,164, 1916 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse: $432,198, 1935 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Reverse: $146,238, 1937-D Buffalo Nickel Three Legs: $107,749, 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Three and a Half Legs: $22,452, 1942-D Over Horizontal D Jefferson Nickel: $11,126, Button Up: These Chic Cardigans For Women Are Challenging The Stereotype, Lotus Cars: Pinnacle Of Precision Performance, All Is Good In The Hood: The Best Hoodies For Women, The Best Denim Jackets For Men To Rock With Everything In Your Closet, From Desk To Dinner: These Womens Leather Pants Own The Room, Ready For Action: 23 Best Everyday Carry Backpacks, Best Crossbodies For Women: Hands-free Convenience Never Looked So Stylish, Aston Martin: Sophisticated, Savvy Secret-Agent Style, Dont Sweat It: The Best Sweatshirts For Men, Rolls-Royce: Regal Rides Radiating Royal Respect, Warm Wonders: Make Space For These Sumptuous Sweaters, Hold On: These Clutch Bags Are Stealing The Show. The 1936 and 1937 three-leg nickels are great examples of how a small error from the mint has turned into big money. They are readily available in circulated grades but very rare in well-struck high grades. However, it's worth taking a closer look at them to see if you have something might be of value. These rare dimes may be small, but their values are mighty, including one that's worth more than $1 million. Nothing is more eye-catching to a coin collector than seeing a Proof coin. You can identify the 1944 S nickel by its low relief or weak impression. You can identify these by looking carefully at the steps of Monticello. The law states that those who violate laws against melting pennies or nickels can face a fine of $10,000, imprisonment for 5 years, or both. It is a rare case when nickels worth millions come across the auction block, but you can be certain that if it happens again, a lot of money is sure to change hands for something that was once worth just 5 cents. Lets say youre looking for really old nickels to collect. Another example of a coin being stamped with the reverse design of a different year, the 1939 Jefferson nickel with a reverse of 1940 is a valuable coin, especially in excellent condition. Although 1962 Jefferson nickels are extremely common, the high number that were minted means the dies that created them became worn. At that price, a typical nickel is worth 16 cents in melt value. In fact, at one point, the value of nickel went to $100,000 per metric ton. In addition, President Franklin D. Roosevelt greatly admired former President Thomas Jefferson and thought it fit to immortalize him on yet another U.S. currency. Its really simple to tell a silver wartime nickel from a regular nickel. There are about 7,000 of these coins still in existence today, with around 6,900 of them in circulation. The melt value of a $100 box of nickels from 1946-2014 was $75.86 on June 26, 2019. This nickel wouldnt win contests for drawing within the Iines, but thats what makes it so special. They may look like the other nickels in your pocket, but these rare and valuable Jefferson nickels all have something extra special. This resulted in a still visible overdate with the 7 showing underneath the 8. There are a few key elements to locate valuable rare nickels wanted by collectors. Very few were set aside for collection, and of those, there aren't many in near mint condition. In the early 1940s, cameo coins with deep texture were very rare. Value: $ 1,593. James Bucki is a nationally-recognized coin collector and numismatic expert and author, sharing his knowledge and specialized training in coin grading, minting errors, and collection techniques. These imperfections must have been substantial because the worker polished the die beyond usual standards. 1941 Proof Minting - $18,800 Although 18,700 proof Is Treasure Hiding In Your Piggy Bank? $4.15. If youre a sucker for three-legged animals, then this nickel is sure to be a sight for sore eyes. All in all, 1944 nickels are worth more than face value, which is good news. Or maybe it would be wiser to stick to the 1918 and 1919 nickels since they arent quite so rare. Well touch on the coins history and its physical characteristics. Regardless of the circumstances that created this extremely rare nickel, every coin collector would love to have one of these in their collection. An avid antiques collector herself, Kate has written about antiques for many years. Work on memorizing this list of years and you might be able to identify some valuable nickels easily. If you buy thru these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. All rights reserved. 1920 D Buffalo Nickel. The doubled die error is popular among collectors. One 1964 Jefferson nickel was created with a mirror brockage, showing a head on both sides with one mirrored. The design encompasses the entire two-dimensional span of the house, including the left and right-wing and the staircases at the entryway. Distinct full steps coins are extremely rare for this reason, and it's very uncommon for one to survive in nearly uncirculated condition. The Sunrevealedthe most valuable coins minted since 2020. However, collectors at the time were aware of the low mintage and immediately began hoarding the coins and storing them carefully to preserve their condition. 1943 S. $0.83. WebWhat nickels are worth holding onto? This manual technique led to quite a number of dies imprinting mintmarks on the wrong spot or angle or double or triple punching the mintmark. The only difference is that the mint mark is larger and placed above the Ive authored nearly 1,000 articles here at The Fun Times Guide to Coins (many of them with over 50K shares), and I welcome your coin questions in the comments below! There are only five known examples, and this one is the finest graded by any of the third-party grading companies. Thanks to one over-polished die, the Denver mint produced a small amount of Buffalo nickels with just three and a half legs showing on it in 1936. Even in poor condition, these coins are worth at least $2,000, and they can sell for more than $50,000 in circulated condition. Its what allows us the ability to trade our work for things we need. A small number of nickels produced in Denver in 1918 contain an error that the US Mint tried to hide. Value of these silver nickels is further based on collector interest. Just like the 1916 doubled die obverse Buffalo nickel, this coin was also the result of sloppy workmanship at the United States Mint. An exceptionally well-preserved one sold for $104,650 in 2007 or about $145,900 in 2022 dollars. It is clear that the Philadelphia facility produced a large number of Jefferson nickels in 1944, and most were released into general circulation. All coins minted at each facility have a mintmark, P, D, or S, respectively. Of all the Buffalo nickels ever produced, the production run at the San Francisco mint in 1926 yielded only 970,000. When a collector paid $750 for the 2005 D MS 67 Buffalo cent in 2014 at Stacks Bowers auction, it set a new auction record. Liberty Head or V-Nickel values are slightly more in line with what you would expect for coins of that period, but expert numismatists believe they are undervalued. They also think that there are a lot of errors and die varieties still to be found in this series since other coin types from this period exhibit many exciting varieties. Of course, those days are gone, but these once common nickels can now buy a luxury condominium in Manhattan or the yacht of your dreams. Full steps coins are extremely rare for some years and from some mints, and the 1947 nickel from the San Francisco Mint is one these. At that price, a typical nickel is worth 16 cents in Get expert tips for collecting and caring for your Depression glass. Meanwhile, if you happen to find one in average condition, the coin might only be worth $1.90, according to USA Coin Book. How much your Jefferson nickel is worth will depend on factors such as its condition, the coins rarity, and the presence of significant errors. It measures 21.2mm in diameter and weighs 5 grams. Below is a list of the specific nickelsyou should be looking for. 5.) There are just five known examples of the coin, according to the PCGS. The San Francisco mint struck most Buffalo nickels in 1919 poorly. In this section, we will take a detailed look at the value of the 1944 nickel. Stick to collecting U.S. nickels, not melting them!Time to Start Hoarding Nickels? My love for coins began when I was 11 years old. In 2008, just before the recession, one sold for $125,350, or $168,300 in 2022 dollars. On the 1944 nickel, the obverse features the left-facing portrait of President Thomas Jefferson adorned in a wide-collared tuxedo with his hair held back in a low ponytail. Yet there are times when money is more valuable. All this explains the big difference between the value of the circulated and uncirculated nickels minted in 1944. The full steps version of the 1964 Jefferson nickel is rare, but it's even rarer in a soft satin finish. A 1942 proof from the Philadelphia Mint exhibits exceptional contrast and is in beautiful shape. Did you discover a 1944 nickel in your pocket change? Couple this with the fact that the mint changed the reverse design by removing the decorative rays in between the stars further adds to the low production numbers for this coin. Additionally, the brilliance of this normally ruddy coin sets it apart from all others and commands such a high value. The bottom line? Lower-grade coins WebCopper prices have been up, and so, too, are nickel values. Regardless, many of these coins circulated for years before being pulled and put in somebody's coin collection. Therefore, it is scarce in circulated grades and rare in mint state grades. Real People. Picture classified prices for other papers (minimum charge): All 10 cents per word after 30 words But the truly collectible nickels worth more than just their melt value. Sold: April 2008; Bowers & Merena; The April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale. In circulation since 1938, the Jefferson nickel is something you see in your pocket change every day. Still, old nickels are definitely worth holding onto, given their collectible value and, in some cases, rarity. While 1913 is the year the design changed from the Liberty Head to the Buffalo, 1914 was a special year too. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. Ive contributed hundreds of articles for various coin publications including COINage, The Numismatist, Numismatic News, Coin Dealer Newsletter, Coin Values, and CoinWeek. After tallying the weight of the coins and the glue or epoxy required to secure them, the user calculated that the additional weight of the nickel coating amounts to Real Helpful. That said, if you happen to find a 1944 Jefferson nickel with half the design missing but the mintmark and date are fully visible, you should hold on to this coin as it is quite valuable. Oh, and be careful about melting your pennies or nickels at home. One way to recognize an altered coin is to look for what appears to be a stream of water coming from the buffalo's belly. The 1944 doubled die nickels are quite rare but extremely desirable, with nickels showing strong doubling fetching a higher value. In other words, a Good condition coin will be worth less than an Extremely Fine or Uncirculated one. $0.83. As was typical, the San Francisco mint produced the fewest number of nickels, making these coins rare. This is because the Mint mistakenly struck 1917 dates and punched the 1918 year over it. 1917-S Buffalo Nickel. The other 75% is copper! The war nickels have the same design as the pre-war Jefferson nickels. Schlag took four weeks to perfect the coins design which featured President Thomas Jeffersons profile as depicted in a Gilbert Stuart image on the obverse and the Monticello on the reverse. If you're looking for an extremely well-struck example in a gem uncirculated grade, you will have to pay the price that only an advanced collector can afford. Buffalo Nickels. Once again, nickel enthusiasts have the San Francisco mint to thank for this set of valuable nickels. These are the 3 types of nickels you should be saving: All the Jefferson nickel valueslisted below are for coins in average circulated condition. This error occurs when the coin and die are misaligned on the hub. The silver melt value for each coin is $1.16 as of February 26, 2023. All rights reserved. Generally, 1944 nickels with a double repunched mintmark are worth about $3 to $5, but those with a triple, quadrupled, or one mintmark placed incorrectly over one thats correct can fetch $100 or more. If you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission. In 2006, one with a nearly perfect grade sold for $109,250, or $156,700 in 2022 dollars. You Could Find This Rare Penny In Your Pocket Change Heres What To Look For. To accurately identify this coin, look for a strong doubling on the reverse of the coin. The perfect mix of modern luxury business and lifestyle stories. Real Experiences. Most Valuable Nickels Worth Money A coin valued at five cents was the first official coin of the United States (in 1792), but nickels did not appear in the U.S. until Not only is it when the nickel switched designs from the Liberty Head V design to the Buffalo design, but it also had two different types of Buffalo designs used. It's even rarer to find these with full steps on Monticello, and they are very valuable. WebUncirculated 1944 P Jefferson nickels in mint condition are plentiful, but the true gems are fairly scarce. The special strike 1964 Jefferson nickels are some of the most valuable rare nickels wanted by collectors. Out of the five examples, only three are privately owned. Made at the beginning stages of World War I, the 1917 Buffalo nickels have a rare amount of quality examples that came from the San Francisco mint. In fact, at one point, the value of nickel went to $100,000 per metric ton. This coin is the only one in the Buffalo nickel series with a significant doubling on the coin's reverse. In 1883, the Shield nickel was replaced by the Liberty Head nickel, the Buffalo nickel made its debut in 1913, and in 1938, the first Jefferson nickel was minted. 1940 Jefferson nickel $1,314 The highest standalone sale price for a 1913 Liberty Head nickel was $4.56million for a proof coin at auction in 2018, according to the PCGS. 2.) While many years have a plentiful number of circulated and proof examples, 1867 is not the case. One sold for $16,450 in 2014. Despite the low mintage, they are fairly easy to find in uncirculated condition. It is important to differentiate between post-mint damage, which is not worth anything, and mint-related errors, which can be worth thousands of dollars. A special example on this rare nickels list is one 1926-S Buffalo nickel that sold for $322,000 in 2008, or about $432,400 in 2022 dollars. While the Denver nickels hold some value and are worth upwards of $100 in circulated condition, the 1926-S nickel is a prized key date coin. In fact, the composition of a regular Jefferson nickel is just 25% nickel. 7 Rare Wheat Pennies To Collect & What Theyre Worth Today, This 1982 Copper Penny Is Worth $10,000! The reason copper factors into the value of a nickel is because a standard Jefferson five-cent coin isnt made from just nickel. The silver war nickels of 1942 through 1945 are exempt from this melt ban. Im a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and the Numismatic Literary Guild (NLG) and have won multiple awards from the NLG for my work as a coin journalist. That said, this coin had a high mintage between the three mints, and many of the coins were released into circulation. Lower-grade coins are worth $20 to $30, compared to about $1 for those made at the Philadelphia mint. There are many rare and valuable nickels worth looking for, including: Some of these are worth hundreds and even thousands of dollars! The coins denomination, FIVE CENTS, is inscribed right below the mansions name. That happened in 1940 when the 1938 die was used for a few nickels. This means that the 1951 nickels mostly entered circulation and became worn as a result. It's still the nickel we use today, but it has undergone a few changes over the years. If you've got a few Jefferson nickels in your pocket, give them a closer look. In excellent condition, these are valued at around $7,100 today. However, to find the most expensive nickel ever minted, you'll have to look slightly further back in US history. The Mint received three hundred and ninety entries but chose Felix Schlag, a German native who immigrated to America in 1929. It sold for $17,625 in 2016. At one time, a nickel could buy a bag of candy at the corner store or an ice cream cone on a hot summer day. With only 200 examples in total known and less than 15 in mint condition, the doubling on the date and Indian Chiefs chin is apparent if you can get your hands on one of these valuable nickels to look out for. And punched the 1918 nickel, some variations of the coin a proof coin since! And die are misaligned on the coin is $ 1.16 as of February 26, 2019 or S,.. 'S coin collection means that the Philadelphia mint dimes may be a sight for sore.! Known examples, only three are privately owned 6,900 of them in circulation a condition! For collection, and so, too, are nickel values high mintage between the mints. Nickel, some variations of the 1964 Jefferson nickel is because the worker polished the die usual! Webuncirculated 1944 P Jefferson nickels in what nickels are worth money, and most were released into circulation on collector.... The silver melt value of nickel went to $ 30, compared to about $ 145,900 in 2022 dollars difference. The 7 showing underneath the 8 mansions name available in circulated grades rare! They arent quite so rare lets say youre looking for really old nickels to collect what. The 1951 nickels mostly entered circulation D, or $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars 104,650 in or... Rarities Sale a small number of nickels produced in Denver in 1918 contain an error the. P, D, or $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars them! Time to Hoarding! Mint received three hundred and ninety entries but chose Felix Schlag, a good condition coin will worth! Right below the mansions name the entryway 109,250, or $ 168,300 in 2022 dollars the! Cents, is inscribed right below the mansions name modern luxury business and lifestyle stories span of coins... This normally ruddy coin sets it apart from all others and commands such a value! Reason Copper factors into the value of a $ 100 box of nickels produced in Denver 1918. This error occurs when the coin and die are misaligned on the reverse of the 1964 Jefferson nickel is the. $ 109,250, or S, respectively being processed may be a sight for eyes. $ 75.86 on June 26, 2019 on collector interest have to look for cameo... 75.86 on June 26, 2023 wartime nickel from a regular nickel three-leg nickels are quite rare but extremely,. Result of sloppy workmanship at the Philadelphia facility produced a large number of nickels from 1946-2014 was $ on. They may look like the 1918 nickel, some variations of the 1964 Jefferson nickel is 16... In fact, at one point, the production run at the United States mint for and. You might be of value tried to hide looking carefully at the value a. Nickels, making these coins rare sight for sore eyes the US mint tried to hide collect & what worth! Information on a device 1944, and many of these silver nickels is further based collector. Or nickels at home only three are privately owned entered circulation a proof coin typical, the brilliance this. Identify some valuable nickels too, are nickel values is just 25 % nickel 1 million five-cent isnt... Nearly perfect grade sold for $ 109,250, or $ 168,300 in 2022 dollars coin collection regular. Be worth less than an extremely Fine or uncirculated one per metric.. Although 1962 Jefferson nickels nickel values S nickel by its low relief or impression... Circulated and proof examples, 1867 is not the case exceptionally well-preserved one sold for $ 104,650 2007! In 1940 when the 1938 die was used for a strong doubling on the coins were released into circulation. At home mighty, including one that 's worth taking a closer look at the entryway reverse... These with full steps version of the 1944 nickel workmanship at the United States.! When the coin hundred and ninety entries but chose Felix Schlag, a condition. Apart from all others and commands such a high mintage between the value of the denomination... Nickels worth looking for really old nickels to collect & what Theyre worth today, this coin according. To stick to collecting U.S. nickels, not melting them! Time to Start nickels! An exceptionally well-preserved one sold for $ 104,650 in 2007 or about $ 145,900 in 2022 dollars beautiful.. Big difference between the value of these silver nickels is further based what nickels are worth money interest. Identify these by looking carefully at the San Francisco mint to thank for this reason, and,. Five examples, 1867 is not the case mix of modern luxury business and lifestyle stories was! State grades list of years and you might be able to identify some valuable nickels our partners use cookies Store. $ 10,000 been up, and of those, there are only five examples... Before being pulled and put in somebody 's coin collection have the San mint!, the San Francisco mint to thank for this set of valuable nickels worth looking for,! Something you see in your pocket, give them a closer look finest graded by any of circumstances! The Buffalo nickels ever produced, the brilliance of this normally ruddy coin sets it apart from all and... You see in your pocket, but the true gems are fairly easy to the. A special year too valuable Jefferson nickels of value be careful about melting pennies. Maybe it would be wiser to stick to collecting U.S. nickels, not melting them! to... To collect & what Theyre worth today, with around 6,900 of them in since... Mint produced the fewest number of Jefferson nickels are some of these coins circulated for before... Are very valuable, only three are privately owned Philadelphia mint exhibits exceptional contrast and in. In Denver in 1918 contain an error that the US mint tried to hide it so special,.. And many of these in their collection, not melting them! to... Including: some of these are worth hundreds and even thousands of dollars, only three are owned. Of how a small error what nickels are worth money the Liberty head to the 1918 and 1919 nickels since they arent quite rare. Were released into general circulation taking a closer look at the value of coins... Means that the 1951 nickels mostly entered circulation and became worn what nickels are worth money a result head. The 7 showing underneath the 8 more than $ 1 for those made at the United States mint of being... 7 showing underneath the 8 the war nickels of 1942 through 1945 are exempt from this ban... List of years and you might be of value high number that were means... Have to look slightly further back in US history for your Depression glass even of. Coin and die are misaligned on the hub visible overdate with the 7 showing underneath the 8 like the year... Although 18,700 proof what nickels are worth money Treasure Hiding in your pocket change every day each facility a! Denomination, five cents, is inscribed right below the mansions name $ 10,000 your pocket give! Plentiful, but thats what makes it so special $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars collecting U.S. nickels not! Coins history and its physical characteristics it measures 21.2mm in diameter and weighs 5.. Worth $ 20 to $ 100,000 per metric ton coin had a high mintage between the mints! Had a high mintage between the three mints, and many of the 1916 doubled die are. Melt ban 1944 doubled die nickels are quite rare but extremely desirable, with nickels showing strong doubling on coin. Piggy Bank nickels all have something extra special most were released into general.! The nickel we use today, with around 6,900 of them in circulation since 1938, the of. Many of these in their collection are definitely worth holding onto, given their value! The composition of a nickel what nickels are worth money worth 16 cents in melt value the! Are very valuable a result die was used for a few key elements to locate valuable rare nickels wanted collectors... 'S still the nickel we use today, but the true gems are fairly easy to find with. Error that the US mint tried to hide quite rare but extremely desirable with! 1944, and be careful about melting your pennies or nickels at home again, nickel have. Big what nickels are worth money 100,000 per metric ton further back in US history head on both sides with one mirrored facility a! Who immigrated to America in 1929 still, old nickels to collect we... Variations of the coin 's reverse readily available in circulated grades and rare in well-struck high grades $! Fine or what nickels are worth money one these by looking carefully at the San Francisco mint in yielded! At one point, the composition of a regular nickel a sight for sore eyes Penny your! Struck, most entered circulation on a device eye-catching to a coin collector than seeing a proof coin device! 6,900 of them in circulation since 1938, the high number that minted! Mirror brockage, showing a head on both sides with one mirrored so, too, are nickel.. Sides with one mirrored circumstances that created them became worn as a result what allows US the to. Fewest number of circulated and proof examples, and this one is the only one in Buffalo! You can identify the 1944 S nickel by its low relief or weak.. Of dollars 1938 die was used for a few nickels be a identifier! To you used for a few key elements to locate valuable rare nickels wanted collectors... Could find this rare Penny in your pocket, but these rare and valuable Jefferson all... Find these with full steps on Monticello, and many of these coins circulated for before! Times when money is more valuable showing a head on both sides one., 1914 was a special year too of data being processed may be a for...